Are You Guilty?

Whether it’s your first Broadway audition or your 171st, you’ll most likely leave wondering whether you did everything you could to nab the role. You’ll want to be sure you caught the eyes of the casting team—and for all the right reasons.

You’ve heard of the Seven Deadly Sins: pride, envy, gluttony, lust, wrath, greed and sloth. Well, with the help of a big-time casting director and a couple of Broadway veterans, Dance Spirit has come up with a list of the Seven Deadly Broadway Audition Sins: self-doubt, defeatism, inattentiveness, unpreparedness, ignorance, lack of training and stiffness. Avoid these or pay the ultimate price: the dreaded rejection.

1. Self-Doubt

When you walk into an audition, a crazy-flexible dancer stretching in the corner will probably make you nervous. And when you hear a fantastic singer belting in the next room, your instinct may be to turn and run. But getting psyched out can sabotage your audition. “As soon as you start watching what everyone else is doing, you’ll begin second-guessing yourself,” says Broadway dancer Samantha Sturm. “Know that you deserve to be in that room as much as everyone else.” Sturm, who’s performed in shows including The Addams Family, Nice Work If You Can Get It and Matilda: The Musical, recommends putting on headphones as soon as you enter the audition site to help you focus. That way, when it’s your time to shine, you can perform as if you’re the best in the room.

According to Benton Whitley, a casting director and partner with Duncan Stewart and Company who’s currently responsible for casting Chicago, that extra boost of self-confidence can push an auditioner from a “maybe” to a “definitely.” “I’m not necessarily looking for the next Kristin Chenoweth,” he says. “But why would I offer a job to someone who can’t confidently sell the package they have?”

For these dancers auditioning for A Chorus Line, attention to detail is crucial. (Photo by Rachel Papo, courtesy Dance Magazine)

2. Defeatism

If you make a mistake during an audition, your instinct may be to wave the white flag. But messing up can actually give you a competitive edge—if you handle it well. “Technical errors happen nightly on a Broadway stage, so it’s helpful to see how you handle it in an audition,” Whitley says. “I want to see if you can move forward without insecurity or embarrassment.”

When 16-year Broadway veteran Kristen Gorski-Wergeles was first starting out, she asked to restart her song after making a mistake during a vocal call. To this day, the ensemble dancer (and former assistant dance captain) for Wicked says it’s her biggest audition regret. “I shouldn’t have been so apologetic,” she says. “If you mess up, never get upset. Embrace it and move on.”

3. Inattentiveness

Prove you’re great to work with by making the casting director’s job as easy as possible—which means paying attention to directions. Watch the choreography carefully, and try to pick up every detail. Most of all: Listen to what the directors tell you to do when you’re not dancing. Whitley notes that at every audition, he asks dancers not to mark the combination on the sides of the studio, and at every audition, he sees dancers ignoring his instruction.

4. Unpreparedness

The “business” part of “show business” can be one of the most crucial make-or-break aspects of an audition. Show your professionalism the moment you walk in: Have your resumé, headshot and music in hand, and be sure you’re dressed properly. “It all goes back to following directions,” Whitley says. “I’ll say ‘Bring heels and tap shoes,’ or ‘Show up at 10 am wearing black,’ and performers will still show up incomplete. I’ve watched it cost people jobs time and time again.”

5. Ignorance

Know the show you’re auditioning for. If it’s already on Broadway, go see it, or, at the very least, rent the movie or listen to the soundtrack. This prep will dictate everything from the makeup you apply to the song you prepare. “You can’t sing a classic Gershwin tune for a rock musical,” Sturm says. “It just doesn’t go.” That being said, don’t show up in full costume. Be in the style of the show—all black for Chicago or bright colors for Rock of Ages—but don’t look like you just stepped offstage.

And don’t forget to research the show’s creative team. A casting director will take note if you can refer to him by name on the day of the audition, and knowing some of the past shows a choreographer has worked on can give you an idea of what to expect.

Pay attention even when you're not dancing—the director is taking note. (Photo by Rachel Papo, courtesy Dance Magazine)

6. Lack of Training

“At the end of the day, you need the technique to book the job,” says Gorski-Wergeles. That includes singing, too. “I’ve seen extremely talented dancers who are the perfect look for a show, but when it comes to the singing part of the audition, they blow it,” Whitley says. “I can tell they’re not putting the same work into the singing element as they have for dance.” Up your game by working with a vocal coach to learn the fundamentals of pitch, tone and musicality.

7. Stiffness

“Most choreographers will understand if you can’t remember every single detail,” Sturm says, “but they need to see your personality. What can you bring to their choreography and how does your style match with theirs?” Casting directors are hiring a person—not a robot. So be yourself on audition day.

And even if you don’t get the part, Gorski-Wergeles says, remember that the positive exposure you gain at each audition can still help book a job down the road. “It’s always about what they’re looking for in the moment,” she says. “You may not be right for something now, but you’ll be right for something else.”


Latest Posts

Photo by Jayme Thornton

How Paloma Garcia-Lee Manifested Her Dream Role, in Steven Spielberg’s "West Side Story"

On a rainy day in November 2018, Paloma Garcia-Lee got a call from her agent that brought her to her knees outside her New York City apartment: She was going to play Graziella in Steven Spielberg's West Side Story.

The call came after a lengthy audition process with Spielberg in the room, and the role, originated by Wilma Curley on Broadway in 1957 and later portrayed by Gina Trikonis in the 1961 film, was her biggest dream. In fact, it's something Garcia-Lee says she manifested from the day plans for the movie were announced in January 2018. "I wrote in my journal: 'I am playing Graziella in Steven Spielberg's West Side Story.'"

Keep Reading SHOW LESS
Photo by @mediabyZ

Am I Less Committed to Dance Because I Have Other Passions? (Spoiler Alert: NO!)

Let's face it—dance is HARD, and in order to achieve your goals, you need to be committed to your training. "Still, there's a fine line between being committed and being consumed." Dancers can, and should, have interests outside of the studio.

Not convinced? We talked with dance psychologist Dr. Lucie Clements and two multifaceted dancers, Kristen Harlow (a musical theater dancer pursuing a career in NYC and Kentucky) and Kallie Takahashi (a dancer in her final year at New York University's Tisch School of the Arts), and got the inside scoop on how having hobbies outside of dance can inform your artistry, expand your range and help prevent burnout.

Keep Reading SHOW LESS
Photo by Jamayla Burse

Catching Up With Christian Burse, Comp Kid Turned Complexions Rising Star

With her nearly limitless facility, well-timed dynamics and incredible control, Christian Burse's future as a dancer was guaranteed to be bright. A student at the renowned Booker T. Washington High School for the Performing and Visual Arts in Dallas, TX, and at Dance Industry Performing Arts Center in Plano, TX, Burse has consistently made waves: She won first runner-up for Teen Outstanding Dancer at New York City Dance Alliance Nationals in 2019, received a grant for summer study at Juilliard from the Texas Young Masters program in 2020, and was named a YoungArts finalist for dance in 2021.

So, it wasn't all that surprising when Burse announced that, at just 17 years old, she would be joining Complexions Contemporary Ballet as an apprentice for the company's 2021–22 season.

Dance Spirit caught up with Burse to hear all about her first season with Complexions ahead of the contemporary ballet company's run at the Joyce Theater in NYC this month.

Keep Reading SHOW LESS

Editors' Picks

Enter the Cover Model Search