The Contemporary Conundrum

On “So You Think You Can Dance” Season 7, Ashley Galvan and All-Star Mark Kanemura navigated the sensuous choreography of Travis Wall’s so-called jazz number with convincing abandon. Set to Annie Lennox’s soaring anthem “Wonderful,” the dance’s risky lifts, natural gestures and emotional honesty made the performance come alive. Nigel Lythgoe liked Wall’s routine, but thought it belonged in the contemporary category instead of jazz. True, the piece was free of any Fosse or other telltale jazz moves. If performed in a competition setting, Wall’s dance might have been called “lyrical.” The whole issue begged the question, “What exactly is contemporary dance?”

Dance style labels are slippery things, and “contemporary” gets the “Most Murky” award. If you’ve only seen it on “SYTYCD,” you probably think contemporary is synonymous with steamy duets set to pop songs, using a dance vocabulary combining ballet, jazz and modern and most often performed in bare feet. Chances are there are leaps and some eye-popping acrobatic tricks. The dancers are usually trained in ballet and jazz technique and able to lift their legs super high. The woman is generally wearing a short, empire waist dress and the man often forgets his shirt. Wall’s piece could easily be a poster dance for contemporary. Yet that’s just one way of thinking about the term, which means many different things. So what is this hybrid dance style? Dance Spirit set out to investigate “Planet Contemporary Dance.”

Identifying Contemporary Dance

It’s easier to define contemporary by what it’s not: You won’t see tap or character shoes, costumes made of grass or bells strapped to ankles. But contemporary is still a bit abstract.

After talking to a handful of ballet, modern and competition veterans, it became clear that contemporary isn’t a technique. In modern, there are specific techniques, like those created by legends Merce Cunningham and Martha Graham. In ballet, there’s Vaganova, Cecchetti and Balanchine technique, to name a few. According to the dictionary, contemporary means “of a time” and could be a relationship between people or things. For example: Travis Wall is a contemporary of Mia Michaels. But when we talk about contemporary dance, we’re using the word in a different way. Its meaning changes depending on where you fall on the dance spectrum.

Contemporary on the Competition Circuit

Mandy Moore, a contemporary choreographer who’s popular on the convention scene, considers the term wide-open. “Contemporary has become the catch-all word used to define movement that doesn’t fit into traditional categories,” she says. “The style was created and defined by artists who don’t like to ‘color inside the lines.’ Contemporary seems to be this place where different styles can collide and create a new, different look and feel for both the dancer and the audience.”

At competitions and conventions, lyrical may be contemporary’s first cousin. Perhaps the only recognizable difference between the styles is the use of acrobatics in contemporary routines but not in lyrical. Both can use pop music—Sarah McLachlan, Jason Mraz, Imogen Heap and Adele are current favorites—and both usually have ballet or jazz as a base in the choreography.

Contemporary in the Ballet World

In the ballet world, “contemporary” refers to works like George Balanchine’s famous plotless ballets—known as leotard ballets—and the dances of other ballet deconstructors like William Forsythe and Christopher Wheeldon. These choreographers have taken traditional ballet movements and dramatized them. In their pieces, the dancers’ arms are more extreme, fourth position is wider and performers are pushed off balance instead of staying directly on top of their legs. Whether it’s a retelling of classics like The Sleeping Beauty and Afternoon of a Faun or a pure movement ballet focused on intense athleticism, it’s all considered contemporary.

Take Dominic Walsh Dance Theater, an up-and-coming Houston-based boutique ballet company with an international reputation. Though you won’t hear any pop songs at Walsh’s performances, there are plenty of steamy duets. Sometimes there are pointe shoes, sometimes not. Today there are many companies, like Walsh’s, devoted solely to presenting contemporary ballets, including Cedar Lake Contemporary Ballet and Complexions Contemporary Ballet.

Contemporary vs. Modern

You might think contemporary is interchangeable with modern—the words are similar—and you would be wrong. According to Walsh, contemporary is even more modern than modern. “I think of contemporary as having derived from some classical backing, but evolving into a richer, more intricate vocabulary of movement,” Walsh says. “Contemporary, for me, represents current, up-to-date ideas. Modern, to me, refers to a particular time and feels a bit dated.”

Plenty of contemporary choreographers who work in ballet and commercial dance arenas have no background in traditional forms of modern dance at all, and usually they don’t come from the college track, where they’d have taken Lester Horton or Paul Taylor classes. If you come from a competition studio, your class schedule may read only jazz, ballet, lyrical and tap. In a ballet academy, you might get an occasional dose of modern, but not on a regular basis.

That being said, some choreographers who did train in modern, like rising choreographer Monica Bill Barnes, describe their work as “contemporary,” too. Barnes, who studied Martha Graham and Cunningham technique at New York University’s Tisch School of the Arts, often makes hilarious dances that examine the intricacies of performance itself and look nothing like Wall’s or Walsh’s. “I used to say postmodern, but people would ask, ‘What is that?’ Postmodern can be a real conversation killer. It sounds pretentious,” says Barnes. “I bounce all over the map. I studied modern dance, but I don’t intend to continue a particular technique, nor did I dance in a modern company.” She uses the term “contemporary” more by default.

Contemporary in College

The Juilliard School in NYC promises an education in contemporary dance, but faculty member Linda Kent says the word contemporary is still a bit cloudy in her circle. “We had modern, then postmodern, but not another word for what came after that,” says Kent, who danced with Paul Taylor and Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater.

Karen Kohn Bradley, associate professor and director of graduate studies at the University of Maryland, College Park, finds her faculty is in constant discussion about what to call their classes. “Contemporary has a variety of meanings,” she says. “Words are defined by their use. Right now, contemporary casts a broader net.”

A Contemporary Conclusion?

Labels, misleading as they are, give us a ballpark definition. They help us talk about dance. How many times have you gone to see a supposed ballet company performance and not seen a single dance on pointe? Is it still ballet? Probably, yes. If Travis Wall decides to make an abstract dance set to Ravel’s “Bolero” with Bollywood-style moves, is it still contemporary? It could be. Maybe we just need to know that dance is an ever-evolving art form. Labels do their best to define it, and just as soon as they do, something changes. Contemporary may just be an umbrella to encompass much of what we see on stage and television today. It’s confusing for certain, but for now it’s what we have. So go with it. Labels should be as fluid as dance itself.

Bradley sums up the opacity well: “I don’t care what we call it—we don’t have a good word for it yet. How about we just call it dance?"

Ballet Academy East student Stella MacDonald (Erin Baiano)

It's the rite of passage every young ballerina dreams of: getting her first pair of pointe shoes. But it's important to remember that a lot (and we mean a lot) of hard work and technique-honing leads up to this moment—not to mention getting the green light from your teacher. Dance Spirit turned to Jenna Lavin, former Miami City Ballet dancer and principal of the pre-professional division at Ballet Academy East in NYC, for three exercises meant to strengthen, train, and stabilize the muscles you'll be using once you're on pointe.

Keep Reading Show less
Fitness
Rochelle Mendoza-Axle, Courtesy Stiskin

In today's dance world, versatility is key. It's not enough to be a master of one style—even when they specialize in one area, dancers are frequently asked to fuse multiple genres, or step out of their comfort zone for specific projects. With their wide variety of summer programs, Joffrey Ballet School aims to prepare dancers for the demands of a professional career. We asked five faculty members to share how they do this:

Keep Reading Show less
Sponsored by Joffrey Ballet School
Kendra Oyesanya, Marcus Mitchell, and Carlito Olivero (courtesy YouTube/Lionsgate)

Happy "Step Up: High Water" eve, y'all! Everyone's favorite internet dance show makes its triumphant Season 2 return tomorrow, March 20th, on YouTube. In anticipation of the premiere, we turned to Kendra Oyesanya (Poppy), Marcus Mitchell (Dondre), and Carlito Olivero (Davis) for the scoop on all things "Step Up"—from on-set shenanigans, to embarrassing stories, to scenes to watch out for this season (hint: Episode 2's dance battle, and the season finale's final number!).

Keep Reading Show less
Dance News
The cast of "Oklahoma!" during last year's run at St. Ann's Warehouse (Teddy Wolff, courtesy DKC/O&M)

You may think you know Oklahoma!, the classic Rodgers and Hammerstein musical that made history when it first opened in 1943 and is best known for Agnes de Mille's groundbreaking dream ballet. But the latest Broadway iteration of the musical isn't your average trip to the frontier. Opening April 7, the revival features new choreography by Mark Morris alum John Heginbotham, and swaps the traditional windswept-prairie set and full orchestra for an intimate, minimalistic staging and a bluegrass band. Coming fresh off an acclaimed run at St. Ann's Warehouse in Brooklyn, the daring, unconventional production is sure to turn heads when it begins previews on Broadway tonight. Dance Spirit caught up with Heginbotham to get all the details on the dancing, and what it was like choreographing his first Broadway show.

Keep Reading Show less
Trending-posts
BLACKPINK has worked with A-list choreographers, including Kyle Hanagami and Parris Goebel.

K-pop is in the middle of a stateside takeover. South Korea's boy bands and girl groups can always be counted on to produce catchy, upbeat songs—and, most importantly for us dance fans, to feature colorful choreography prominently in their music videos. Over the past few years, the K-pop machine has been churning out a seemingly endless stream of talented groups with choreography worth watching on repeat, and some of them are starting to make names for themselves in the U.S. Check out our list of the dancetastic K-pop bands you need to know.

Keep Reading Show less
Commercial
Briar Nolet did NOT come to play. (NBC)

Have you ever felt that the Duels round on NBC's "World of Dance" was a bit unfair? During the Duels, each act's success hinges not on how objectively good they are, but on how good they are relative to a single challenger. Which means that mediocre acts can move forward if they best slightly-more-mediocre opponents, while frontrunners who're given tougher matchups end up knocked out.

Newly-engaged goddess J.Lo and her team get that. Which is why, last night, "WOD" introduced a twist designed to make the Duels more just: a redemption round. Formerly, five acts were eliminated in each division during the Duels. But from here out, the two highest scorers of those five will go head-to-head to earn a wild card spot. And that made last night's Upper Division Duels significantly more exciting.

Who just dueled it? Who was redeemed? Who made Derek Hough scream like a teenage girl? Onward to the episode highlights!

Keep Reading Show less
Dance on TV
American Ballet Theatre principal Devon Teuscher (left) meeting with Bloch owner David Fox (right) in NYC. (Marius Bugge for Bloch)

For professional ballet dancers, the search for the perfect pointe shoe is a lifelong quest. Even the smallest adjustment in manufacturing can make the difference between a shoe that allows a ballerina to soar and a shoe that detracts from her dancing. So what goes into creating the perfect fit? A lot of hard work, patience, and masterful attention to detail. We got the inside scoop on how a Bloch pointe shoe is made from beginning to end, and went inside one of American Ballet Theatre principal Devon Teuscher's touch-up fittings with Bloch owner David Fox in NYC.

Keep Reading Show less
Ballet
Martina Sandionigi as Giselle

We updated your favorite story-ballet tutus with modern details that'll please any 21st-century prima ballerina. Who needs a cavalier, anyway?

Keep Reading Show less
Dance Fashion
Dancers are total brainiacs.

Dancing impacts pretty much every aspect of our lives—including our brains. That's right: Dance makes us smart. Like, super smart. Here are seven ways being a dancer enhances your brainpower.

Keep Reading Show less
Just for Fun
Ballet Academy East student Stella MacDonald (Erin Baiano)

It's the rite of passage every young ballerina dreams of: getting her first pair of pointe shoes. But it's important to remember that a lot (and we mean a lot) of hard work and technique-honing leads up to this moment—not to mention getting the green light from your teacher. Dance Spirit turned to Jenna Lavin, former Miami City Ballet dancer and principal of the pre-professional division at Ballet Academy East in NYC, for three exercises meant to strengthen, train, and stabilize the muscles you'll be using once you're on pointe.

Keep Reading Show less
Fitness
The ultimate dance mom: Debbie Allen with her daughter, Vivian Nixon (courtesy Nixon)

Dance moms: Where would we be without them? We all know how much support and help they give us—in addition to loads of love. Here are 10 reasons real-life dance moms are undeniably the best.

Keep Reading Show less
Dancer to Dancer
Photo by Samantha Little

It's the fall of 2018. As the Brigham Young University Cougarettes step onto the field at LaVell Edwards stadium in Provo, UT, a crowd of nearly 64 thousand erupts into cheers. The dancers take their places, and a feeling of anticipation hangs in the air: Their reputation precedes them.

The music—Ciara's banger "Level Up"—begins, and unbelievable precision ensues. Eighteen dancers attack the highly technical choreography, which nods at viral social-dance sensations and continuously builds in energy. The school's mascot, Cosmo the Cougar, joins the team on the field, and the audience goes wild. As the piece ends, the sound in the stadium is deafening. The 16-time national-title-winning group has proved once again why they're the standard for college dance team success—they're just that good.

Keep Reading Show less
Dance Team
Paloma Garcia-Lee (center, in gold) and the cast of "Fosse/Verdon" (FX)

The extraordinary Paloma Garcia-Lee, who's danced in no fewer than five Broadway shows, can adapt to any choreographer's style. And before heading back to Broadway this spring in Moulin Rouge! (choreographed by Sonya Tayeh), she's tackling the work of one of the most iconic choreographers of all time: Bob Fosse.

Garcia-Lee plays Adrienne in the new FX limited series "Fosse/Verdon," premiering April 9, which follows the romantic and creative relationship of Fosse (Sam Rockwell) and his muse Gwen Verdon (Michelle Williams). Hamilton's Lin-Manuel Miranda, Thomas Kail, Steve Levenson, and Andy Blankenbuehler serve as executive producers, with Kail directing and Blankenbuehler choreographing.

With the exception of performing on The Tony Awards, "Fosse/Verdon" marks Garcia-Lee's TV debut. "I'm really setting my sights on more on-camera work," she says. "Getting the chance to flex my muscles as an actress in this different medium, but still have the dance part, is all really exciting." (She's got real acting chops, too: While a student at the North Carolina School of the Arts, she actually quit dance briefly to study acting instead.)

Dance Spirit spoke to Garcia-Lee about "Fosse/Verdon"'s epic final callback, how she got cast, and the transition from stage to screen.

Keep Reading Show less
Dance on TV

Video

mailbox

Get Dance Spirit in your inbox

Giveaways